Family engagement in the child welfare system: A scoping review

Karmen Toros, Diana DiNitto, Anne Tiko - Children and Youth Services Review

Abstract

Objective

This article describes the results of a scoping review to better understand child welfare professionals' and service users' (families' and children's) perspectives on and experiences with family engagement in the child protection system.

Method

Forty peer-reviewed academic journals from multiple scientific databases published in English between January 1, 2010 and May 31, 2016 were analysed.

Results

Aspects of traditional child protection discourse still tends to dominate engagement practices, including the over-riding priority of child protection concerns; authority-based, coercive, and bureaucratized methods of engaging clients; children's participation as perfunctory rather than an important aspect of the process; limited information from the workers to children and families; and processes that are stigmatizing, focusing on families' deficits rather than strengths.

Conclusions and implication for practice

To improve the quality of relationships between workers and children/families, and, most importantly, to improve child welfare outcomes, a paradigm shift is needed, recognizing children's and families' rights and the importance of their participation, Methods are needed that help child welfare professionals to increase their competence and confidence in engaging children and families effectively in child protection processes, including assessment that have critical implications for clients' lives.